Plant Pathology

Soft rot Pectobacteriaceae (SRP) are among the most economically important plant pathogenic bacteria and are especially known to be problematic in potato production. The epidemiology of disease transmission has been investigated for almost a century, and several aspects have been highlighted as plausible infection routes. However, it is generally accepted that the major source of disease is the latently infected mother tuber, but several parameters are still influencing disease prevalence including contaminated equipment, soil water status as well as temperature. Management of the disease is limited to hygiene practices, dry storage and seed certification systems but several studies have also proven biocontrol agents such as bacteriophages (phages) as promising tools. Despite the severity of SRP on potato production, little is known about the genetic diversity of SRPs in Denmark, and since only few isolates are available, the possibility to design a broadly effective phage cocktail is limited. Here we describe a three-year field study utilizing an agri-citizen science approach where Danish farmers provided symptomatic potato plants or tubers, together with metadata such as date, location, potato variety and origin. By using whole genome sequencing (Illumina and Nanopore) together with metadata we were able to investigate and monitor the epidemiological disease spread across the country using 103 complete genomes, sampled across all three years. In this study we provide epidemiological evidence of disease origins and a suite of phages that could be used as a biocontrol tool for early disease intervention. Our results revealed several clonal clades across diverse locations (SNPs < 20) which strongly indicate common origin. A total of 17 Pectobacterium phages were tested and did target > 80% of clonal clades. Based on the clonality across the soft rot isolates we propose the possibility to set in early on using phages targeting strains relevant for soft rot development, with the possibility of a surveillance program together with customizing the phage preference.

BackgroundPotato is an important crop worldwide, yet its production is severely threatened by Phytophthora infestans, the causal agent of late blight. Alternatives to the current control strategies are needed, as these rely heavily on environmentally harmful treatments. The recruitment of beneficial microbes by plants upon stress ("cry-for-help" mechanism) may represent an opportunity to find new biocontrol agents but this has not yet been reported for potato. The aim of this study was to analyse whether foliar late blight infection induces shifts in the phyllosphere, rhizosphere and soil bacterial communities associated with two potato cultivars of differing sensitivity to late blight. Moreover, we aimed at isolating members of the plant microbiota to test whether bacteria putatively recruited upon infection would be particularly active in protecting the plant against late blight. ResultsControlled foliar infection triggered substantial, cultivar-specific shifts in the rhizosphere communities across two successive generations. Despite the number of differentially abundant ASVs detected being ten times higher in the second generation than in the first one, the same taxonomic groups were concerned by the shifts: Burkholderiales, Flavobacteriales, and Bacillales. Furthermore, the communities linked to the susceptible cultivar consistently shifted more strongly than the communities linked to the resistant cultivar. The obtained ASV sequences were used to identify 163 corresponding isolates. The inhibition potential of these strains against P. infestans spores was assessed through biological assays, which revealed the biocontrol potential of strains otherwise not yet known to inhibit phytopathogenic organisms, such as Advenella, Nocardioides and Phyllobacterium strains. Although we found no correlation between the relative abundance shift of the ASVs upon infection and the activity of the corresponding strains, we observed that the overall activity of strains isolated from the resistant cultivar was higher than that of the strains isolated from the susceptible one. ConclusionTaken together, the higher activity of the strains isolated from the resistant cultivar, along with its comparatively modest microbiome shifts upon infection suggest that the investigated resistant cultivar might harbour specific microbiota enriched in strains with efficient protective abilities against their host plants pathogens, which possibly contribute to its higher resistance against P. infestans.

Australia is the largest producer of Pyrethrum (Tanacetum cinerariifolium) globally. Amongst the constraints on production are the fungal pathogens Didymella tanaceti and Stagonosporopsis tanaceti, which pose a significant threat to the industry, causing substantial yield losses. While the infection biology of S. tanaceti is well characterised, knowledge of D. tanaceti and its potential interaction with S. tanaceti on plants remains limited, hindering disease management. We developed fluorescently labelled strains of both pathogens via Agrobacterium tumefaciens-mediated transformation (ATMT). Binary vectors carrying the mNeonGreen or tdTomato fluorescent protein genes were introduced into D. tanaceti and S. tanaceti, respectively, and expression of the fluorescent proteins was confirmed by microscopy. Genome sequencing revealed single-copy T-DNA insertions in all transformants, with minor genomic rearrangements at insertion sites. Detached leaf assays demonstrated that transformed strains retained pathogenicity, producing disease symptoms indistinguishable from those of the wild type. These fluorescently labelled variants enabled detailed visualisation of D. tanaceti infection biology and its interactions with S. tanaceti, including co-infection dynamics. Co-infection assays using fluorescent strains further facilitated simultaneous visualisation and differentiation of both pathogens within host tissues. Importantly, these tools also allowed the first description of the early stages of infection by D. tanaceti in pyrethrum leaves. This study represents the first successful transformation of D. tanaceti and S. tanaceti, providing valuable resources to investigate their infection processes.

2.Hairy root disease (HRD), caused by rhizogenic Agrobacterium, is an economically important disease affecting hydroponic tomato (Solanum lycopersicum L.) production worldwide. HRD-affected plants show extensive root proliferation, resulting in decreased energy expenditure towards fruit production. Host plant susceptibility to rhizogenic Agrobacterium is typically evaluated through artificial wounding-based infection bioassays. However, under natural infection settings, rhizogenic Agrobacterium can induce disease symptoms without deliberate, artificial wounding. We developed a soil-based, non-wounding bioassay that closely mimics natural rhizosphere interactions and permits quantitative and qualitative assessment of HRD symptoms. The assay measured root dry weight, documented agravitropic root development typical of HRD and confirmed in planta T-DNA gene expression using reverse transcriptase quantitative polymerase chain reaction (RT-qPCR). We used this bioassay to evaluate disease symptoms towards rhizogenic Agrobacterium in tomato cv. Moneymaker and the rootstocks Optifort, Maxifort, and Arnold. Optifort and Maxifort exhibited significantly higher root biomass than Arnold and Moneymaker, indicating more pronounced symptom development. The bioassay also differentiated virulence levels amongst various rhizogenic Agrobacterium strains isolated from HRD-affected plants. Together, these results show that our soil-based bioassay provides a robust and ecologically relevant platform for screening tomato genotypes and comparing virulence levels of rhizogenic Agrobacterium strains supporting resistance breeding and disease management efforts.

Leaf diseases pose a serious threat to faba bean production. Leaf blotch of faba bean, caused by Alternaria spp., has become increasingly widespread and destructive in several countries. Leaf diseases pose a serious threat to faba bean production. The infection of plant by pathogens can be influenced by various factors associated with the host plant, environmental conditions and presence of other microorganisms. The phyllosphere and endosphere play a critical role in plant health and disease development. This study aimed to evaluate the factors shaping the structure and diversity of fungal communities associated with faba beans. Plant samples were collected in 2004 from two intensively managed faba bean production fields in the central region of Latvia. Fungal assemblages were characterized using an ITS region metabarcoding approach based on Illumina MiSeq sequencing. Among the assigned amplicon sequence variant (AVS), 65% belonged to the phylum Ascomycota, while approximately 4% were classified as Basidiomycota. Alternaria and Cladosporium were the dominant genera across samples. The alfa and beta diversities of fungal communities was higher during flowering of faba beans to compare with ripening. The higher abundance of Basidiomycota yeasts were observed during flowering, in contrast, Cladosporium genus was significantly more abundant during ripening. Alternaria DNA was found on leaves that showed no symptoms of the disease. The diversity and composition of fungal communities were significantly influenced by sampling time and presence of leaf blotch, caused by Alternaria spp.

Breeding disease-resistant varieties (DRV) is a central strategy for reducing reliance on phytosanitary products. However, the successful deployment and long-term durability of these cultivars rely on acquiring field data across diverse production conditions, a step that remains frequently neglected, especially in perennial crops. Since 2018, the OSCAR observatory, a network of vineyard plots planted in France with varieties resistant to downy and powdery mildew, the two major pathogens of grapevine, has aimed to close this gap for viticulture. The observatory comprises over 199 commercial plots, covering 127 hectares across diverse agroclimatic conditions, all managed by winegrowers under their own production practices. The observatory currently monitors 30 disease-resistant grapevine varieties, tracking both their agronomic performance and the dynamics of key pathogens. Since 2018, while phytosanitary treatments have been reduced by an average of 79% compared to conventional plots, the incidence of downy and powdery mildew, remain low, even in years highly conducive to these diseases. However, the long-term survey also highlights the decline in efficacy of some resistances to downy mildew and the emergence of black rot, a disease effectively controlled by conventional phytosanitary programs. Beyond acting as a rapid warning system for resistance breakdown, the observatory promotes sustainable disease management in viticulture. It provides valuable insights to winegrowers on effective DRV management. It also delivers actionable feedback to breeders to guide more durable DRV breeding strategies. Highlights- OSCAR observatory monitors 199 plots of grapevine disease resistant varieties (DRV) - Grapevine DRV cuts fungicide uses by 79% while maintaining good disease control - Some resistances efficacy declines against downy mildew, but not powdery mildew - Black rot, a disease usually controlled by fungicide, is rising in OSCAR plots OSCAR provides useful feedback to breeders and winegrowers on DRV management

Cucurbit yellow vine disease (CYVD), caused by the bacterium Serratia ureilytica, is a phloem-associated disease of cucurbits. This study characterized the spatial and temporal distribution of S. ureilytica in Cucurbita pepo cultivar Delicata plants under greenhouse conditions using a GFP-tagged isolate (P01). Seedlings were sampled weekly for four weeks. Transverse sections from the stem, petiole, leaf, shoot apex, and root were imaged by laser scanning confocal and fluorescent dissecting microscopy. In parallel, bacterial abundance in each plant tissue was assessed by quantifying colony-forming units (CFU) via droplet plating over a 4-week time course. Across plant tissues and time points, S. ureilytica fluorescent signal was primarily concentrated in the inner and outer periphery of the bicollateral vascular bundles, with higher magnification images revealing mainly symplastic localization within phloem-associated cells. Consistent with the imaging results, bacterial quantification data showed a high abundance of CFUs in the main stem across weeks, with an irregular pattern of presence in the distal tissues at later time points. These results suggest that S. ureilytica is predominantly localized within phloem-associated cells and spreads both acropetally and basipetally during infection.

Ralstonia pseudosolanacearum (Rps) belongs to the Ralstonia solanacearum species complex (RSSC). It is a vascular pathogen that causes lethal bacterial wilt disease in many plants, including tomato and eggplant. In this study, we infiltrated tomato leaves with the phytopathogenic bacterium at 109 CFU/mL and observed the development of necrotic scars in the infiltrated area at 48 hours post-infiltration. Interestingly, this response was followed by petiole bending toward the ground of the compound leaf. This was followed by the gradual senescence of the infiltrated leaflet only. In addition, the terminal leaflet infiltrated with the pathogen exhibited epinasty. None of the above symptoms were observed in leaves infiltrated with the known virulent deficient hrpB::{Omega} mutant. Surprisingly, all of the above symptoms were observed in leaves infiltrated with another well-known virulence-deficient mutant phcA::{Omega}. It indicated that the necrotic lesion caused in tomato leaves was hrp-dependent. Infiltration in eggplant leaves caused necrotic scarring and leaf senescence, which were relatively delayed. Necrotic scarring without petiole bending or senescence in tomato leaves was also observed due to infiltration of Pseudomonas aeruginosa SPT08, a tomato endophyte having plant growth promotion activity. The patho-phenotypes such as petiole bending, epinasty, and senescence observed in the case of tomato in this study were not reported earlier. We believe these phenotypes produced in tomato after leaf infiltration may be useful to study the virulence of this pathogen.

Bacterial canker, caused the Pseudomonas syringae species complex, is a major constraint on sweet cherry production worldwide. However, the influence of agronomic practices on pathogen ecology, dispersal and evolution under field conditions remains poorly understood. Here, we combined a factorial-design field experiment with whole-genome sequencing to investigate the effects of polytunnel covering and nitrogen fertigation on phyllosphere populations and the dynamics of a key pathogen, P. syringae pathovar syringae 9644 (Pss9644) in young cherry trees. Epiphytic P. syringae populations initially resembled those in surrounding woodland environments. Over time, pathogenic phylogroup 2d lineages became dominant, particularly on uncovered trees. Diversity of P. syringae populations was higher in uncovered treatments. Polytunnel covering markedly altered community composition and limited rain-splash dispersal of Pss9644 from stem cankers to leaves, thereby interrupting a key stage of the disease cycle. By contrast, nitrogen fertigation had no detectable effect on phyllosphere community structure, but enhanced plant growth and reduced lesion expansion following inoculation. Whole-genome sequencing of re-isolated Pss9644 strains revealed limited short-term genomic diversification, with single-nucleotide polymorphisms detected in 22 re-isolates. In total, 36 mutations were identified across the chromosome although no mutation affected virulence or motility. Taken together, our results show that agronomic practices influence both pathogen ecology and disease outcomes through distinct mechanisms: polytunnel covering primarily limits pathogen dispersal and reshapes phyllosphere communities, while nitrogen fertigation enhances plant growth and reduces disease severity. These findings highlight the potential to integrate canopy management and nutrient strategies to mitigate bacterial canker risk in commercial cherry production.

There is disagreement on whether secondary endosymbionts are found in the major cereal pest aphid, Rhopalosiphum padi. Some papers report a diversity of secondary bacterial endosymbionts while others have failed to find evidence of these bacteria in this species. Here we revisit this issue by summarizing the relevant literature and through additional sampling of the species in Australia, China and Denmark using a combination of molecular approaches. We find a general absence of secondary endosymbionts beyond the obligate endosymbiont Hamiltonella defensa in R. padi. While the inconsistency in survey results may reflect rapid changes in endosymbiont turnover in populations and/or the impact of ecological factors such as host plant type on endosymbiont diversity, we are concerned that technical issues may be at least partly responsible for inconsistencies in the literature. This leads us to emphasize the importance of multiple sources of evidence required to establish and characterize endosymbiont infections, including PCR and qPCR assays, DNA Sanger sequencing and 16SrRNA gene metabarcoding. We note that several major aphid pests show a low incidence of secondary endosymbionts which raises issues about the importance of these endosymbionts in aphids that constitute pests, even though endosymbionts can in some cases increase host fitness and therefore pest impact.

Soybean (Glycine max [L.] Merr.) productivity is frequently compromised by soil-borne pathogens. Macrophomina phaseolina (Mp), the causal agent of charcoal rot, can produce important soybean yield losses especially when hot and dry weather prevails. Integrating biological control agents with chemical seed treatments represents a promising strategy for improving disease management. This study aimed to (i) assess the in vitro compatibility of Trichoderma koningiopsis with commercial fungicide seed treatments, and (ii) evaluate the field performance of T. koningiopsis, alone or combined with compatible fungicides, across three soybean growing seasons. Compatibility assays revealed fungicide-specific effects, with Acronis(R) classified as non-fungitoxic and Topseed Extra as moderately fungitoxic. Across field seasons, Mp inoculation reduced seedling emergence, while several seed treatments improved emergence compared to the inoculated control, however, treatment effects varied markedly among years. Disease severity did not differ significantly among treatments in any season, and yield responses were strongly modified by environmental conditions rather than treatment effects. Temperature-response assays showed that T. koningiopsis exhibited optimal growth between 28 to 30{degrees}C and complete inhibition above 40{degrees}C, indicating high thermal sensitivity. The results demonstrate that T. koningiopsis can be integrated with compatible fungicides and may enhance early stand establishment under favorable conditions, but its field performance is strongly limited by high temperatures. These findings highlight the importance of environmental conditions when biological seed treatments are used.

Longitudinal data on disease susceptibility in forest trees are rare but essential for understanding host-pathogen dynamics and genetic variation in susceptibility traits. We present a long-term multisite common garden dataset quantifying susceptibility of Scots pine (Pinus sylvestris) to Dothistroma needle blight. The dataset comprises annual disease assessments collected from the same trees across 11 years, spanning 168 families and 21 Scottish provenances. This design enables partitioning of genetic and environmental sources of variation, evaluation of temporal stability in host response, and estimation of variance components and narrow-sense heritability of susceptibility. The data support analyses of phenotypic plasticity, provenance-level responses, and interactions between disease susceptibility and other adaptive traits. This resource will facilitate predictive modelling of host susceptibility under current and future environmental conditions.

Beyond the significant impact of Cassava witches broom disease (CWBD), caused by the fungus Rhizoctonia (syn. Ceratobasidium) theobromae on cassava cultivation in French Guiana and Brazil, this disease also poses a potential threat to cacao trees in the region, since the fungus is responsible for Vascular Streak Dieback (VSD) of cacao in South East Asia. Cross-pathogenicity trials were conducted in several cassava fields in French Guiana by planting young cacao plants adjacent to diseased cassava plants. Vascular necrosis was observed in some cacao plants, and the presence of R. theobromae in the cacao tissues was confirmed through PCR diagnostics using primers specific to the fungus. Sequence analysis indicated 100% similarity between samples from both hosts and 97.53 to 99.74% identity with R. theobromae isolates previously reported from cassava in the Americas and Southeast Asia. Additionally, symptomatic cacao in a mixed cacao-cassava farm yielded R. theobromae-positive PCR results, suggesting a natural infection. Ongoing work includes artificial inoculations and controlled cross-pathogenicity trials under screenhouse conditions to attempt reproduction of the symptoms. While current data do not yet establish definitive causality, the findings indicate potential host jump and warrant rapid communication to researchers, policy makers, and farmers to safeguard cacao production and Theobroma biodiversity in the Amazon region.

Aphanomyces euteiches, the causative agent of Aphanomyces root rot (ARR), is of major concern for pea and other legume crops globally. This oomycete pathogen causes substantial decreases in crop yields, is unaffected by most fungicides, and persists in the soil for many years via its resilient oospores. Given the significance of pea crops in sustainable agriculture, namely the ability to fix nitrogen and act as a sustainable protein source, solutions to ARR are of high importance. We used RNA-seq in a novel strain of Pseudomonas donghuensis to identify two biosynthetic gene clusters under GacA/S control that are involved in producing bioactive molecules capable of inhibiting A. euteiches. Based on similarity to other reported clusters in Pseudomonas, the first is predicted to encode for a pseudoiodinine compound, while the second is predicted to produce the siderophore 7-hydroxytropolone. Individual knockouts of each cluster showed loss of inhibitory action of P. donghuensis NRC29 against A, euteiches in vivo. This is the first report highlighting the potential of P. donghuensis and the products of the two identified biosynthetic pathways as biocontrol agents for A. euteiches. Further investigations into the efficacy of P. donghuensis NRC29 and its metabolites in inhibiting A. euteiches in field trials will be of high value in developing sustainable strategies for ARR mitigation. ImportanceModern fungicidal treatments for control of root rot in pulse crops are ineffective for control of A. euteiches, leaving limited strategies for management of A. euteiches infected fields. We describe a novel P. donghuensis strain with potential for biocontrol against this persistent pathogen. Given the economic value of peas and other pulses globally, further work into harnessing the bioactive metabolites produced by this strain into a practical in-field treatment will be valuable.

Cercospora species associated with soybean cause Cercospora leaf spot and purple seed stain, which are major diseases affecting soybean production worldwide and can lead to significant yield and seed quality losses. However, unstable and poor sporulation under laboratory conditions remains a critical challenge, hindering the recovery of genetically homogeneous isolates and the establishment of standardized experimental protocols. These limitations further restrict our understanding of the biology, epidemiology, and pathogenicity of these pathogens. In this study, we developed specialized legume-based culture media derived from soybean and pea tissues to mimic host-associated environmental conditions. We compared the sporulation efficacy of these media with commonly used artificial media, including potato dextrose agar (PDA) and V8 juice agar. Our results demonstrated that legume-based media consistently supported higher levels of sporulation than PDA and V8 across multiple strains, although conidial yields varied depending on the strain and medium concentration. Transcriptional analysis of sporulation-related genes revealed that while abaA, wetA, and steA did not show significant differential expression among media, velB exhibited distinct medium-dependent expression patterns. Further evaluation using additional field isolates confirmed that legume-based media provide a more reliable method for inducing sporulation than PDA. Overall, legume-based media represent a practical and effective approach for promoting sporulation in soybean-associated Cercospora species under laboratory conditions.

Potato common scab (Streptomyces sp.) is an economically important disease that reduces the quality and market value of tubers. A key aspect in developing management strategies involves accurately quantifying the disease. Due to the three-dimensional nature of the tuber and the heterogeneous distribution of lesions across its surface, visual estimates of severity can be challenging. Therefore, the objectives of this study were to develop and validate a standard area diagram (SAD) for estimating common scab severity on potato tubers and to compare validation outcomes obtained using real tubers and digital images. A SAD comprising six severity levels (from 1.3 to 66.8%) was developed based on image analysis of naturally infected tubers. Validation was conducted using two complementary approaches in which inexperienced raters evaluated either real potato tubers or digital images of the same tubers under unaided and aided conditions. Accuracy, bias components, and inter-rater reliability were quantified using absolute error metrics, Lins concordance correlation coefficient, intraclass correlation coefficients, and overall concordance correlation coefficients. Use of the SAD significantly improved accuracy, reduced systematic bias, and increased inter-rater reliability across both validation approaches. No significant differences were detected between assessments conducted on real tubers and images, although image-based evaluations showed a slight, non-significant tendency toward reduced scale and location bias under aided conditions. These results demonstrate that a dimension-aware SAD integrating information across the full tuber surface enhances the reliability and reproducibility of visual severity assessments and supports the use of image-based evaluations for training, large-scale surveys, and remote or collaborative applications involving three-dimensional plant organs.

Apple blotch, caused by Diplocarpon coronariae, is an increasingly important fungal disease that leads to premature leaf fall and significant yield losses in apple orchards. Breeding resistant cultivars offers a sustainable strategy to reduce disease impact, as all commercial apple cultivars are susceptible to this pathogen. This study aimed to investigate the disease resistance of Malus baccata Jackii-derived offspring to D. coronariae through artificial inoculation and to identify loci associated with resistance. Simple interval mapping was performed using phenotypic and genotypic data from 122 individuals of an F1 population (Idared x M. baccata Jackii), together with analyses of M. baccata Jackii-derived open-pollinated populations. Our results indicate that resistance to apple blotch is a complex, polygenic trait, with four important QTLs identified on linkage groups 1, 2, 12 and 13. Disease severity was strongly affected by inoculum, phenotyping method and environmental factors. These findings have direct implications for apple breeding programmes aimed at developing apple blotch-resistant cultivars.

Grapevine Trunk diseases (GTDs) represent a major threat for the wine industry. Despite several break-through, their etiology remains unclear and no curative treatment is currently available. Wood anatomy and water transport contribute to the symptoms of young plant decline. This study investigates wood anatomical alterations in two Alsatian grapevine cultivars presenting different susceptibility to GTDs, focusing on wood structure over six months of vegetative growth and in response to infection. Using a validated FasGa staining protocol, wood sections from transverse, tangential, and radial directions were stained to differentiate lignified and cellulosic tissues. Microscopic analysis was performed at x4, x10, and x40 magnifications, yielding a dataset of 4771 images. To support this high-throughput quantitative analysis of microscopy images, a computational model was developed, enabling reliable and efficient assessment of anatomical traits. Pre-established woody tissues presented higher xylem vessels diameter in Gewurztraminer than Riesling, with a dorsoventral arrangement whereas the number of vessels remained the same all over the cross section. No significant anatomical changes were observed in established woody tissues, whereas newly formed xylem anatomy showed a possible rearrangement during infection, especially in Gewurztraminer cultivar. Furthermore, colorimetric analysis quantified the lignification of woody tissues in response to wounding damage compared to un-treated plants. While definitive conclusions remain limited due to the experimental timeframe and sample variability, the findings highlight the need for longer-term studies and broader cultivar evaluation. Code and microscopy images have been made publicly available, providing a scalable digital tool for future research in plant vascular systems.

BACKGROUNDEndophytic fungi are naturally inhabiting plant organs without causing disease symptoms. They can also contribute to their hosts pest and disease resistance by displaying entomopathogenic and/or antifungal traits. In this study, we evaluated the ability of 11 strains of avocado fungal endophytes to antagonize three important avocado plant pathogens: Colletotrichum gloeosporioides, Fusarium solani, and Phytophthora cinnamomi, and two insect pests: Sitophilus zeamais and Xyleborus bispinatus. RESULTSThe results show that Trichoderma spp. strains were the most effective against the evaluated plant pathogens in terms of growth inhibition, in direct contact assays or through metabolite production. Other fungi, such as Purpureocillium sp. and Pochonia sp., only exhibited pathogen inhibition through diffusible metabolites but displayed strong insecticidal capacity against the evaluated pests, hence being identified as promising multi-target biocontrol agents in the integrative analysis. CONCLUSIONOur findings evidence the potential of avocado fungal endophytes and their metabolites as multi-target biocontrol agents of crop pests and pathogens.

RNA interference (RNAi) shows great potential to protect crops against fungal diseases, yet reported protection efficiencies vary greatly, and our understanding of the factors responsible for this variance remains limited. In this meta-analysis, we evaluated 89 studies that compare the efficiency of host-induced gene silencing (HIGS) and spray-induced gene silencing (SIGS) in controlling fungal diseases, focusing on biotrophic, hemibiotrophic, and necrotrophic fungi, the use of formulations, and the dsRNA design as explanatory factors for differences between reported efficiency values. Our results indicate that SIGS is slightly more effective, particularly in biotrophs. Surprisingly, SIGS studies using formulations did not outperform those applying naked dsRNA. We also assessed parameters of RNA design. Differences in dsRNA length and the number of constructs, and number of targets showed no consistent significant effect on resistance in either HIGS or SIGS. Interestingly, however, HIGS studies reported significantly higher efficiency when targeting genes closer to the 3 end and SIGS when targeting genes closer to the 5 end. We discuss potential reasons for the reported patterns, such as variability in dsRNA uptake mechanisms, intercellular trafficking and Dicer processing, and conclude that more research is needed to understand the biological mechanisms determining RNAi efficiency for fungal control.